Car Accident Not My Fault, Do I Still Have to Pay The Deductible?


This is a question that our car accident lawyers are frequently asked. Generally, when your vehicle is damaged because of the other driver’s fault, the other driver’s insurance will pay to fix or replace your car, if they agree that their driver was at fault. In that case, you will NOT have to pay a deductible and they will also probably provide you with a rental car while your car is fixed or you shop for a new one.

Car Accident Lawyers MN
Car Accident Lawyers MN

However, there are three circumstances where you would still have to turn the claim over to your own auto insurance company even if the other driver caused the accident:

(1) If the other driver is uninsured,

(2) If the other driver’s insurance company won’t admit the accident was his fault and refuses to pay,

(3) If your car is totaled and you don’t agree with the other insurance company on the fair value of your vehicle.

In these situations, you will have to submit the claim to your auto insurance company if you have collision coverage. Your insurance company will pay to fix or replace your vehicle, but you will have to pay the deductible (at least temporarily) even though the other driver was at fault in the crash. After your insurance company pays to fix or replace your car, they will try to get their money back from the other driver’s insurance or from the other driver if he was uninsured. If your insurance company is successful at getting money from the other driver or his insurer, they will pay you back your deductible at the same time.


Also, if you are injured in a car accident in Minnesota, YOUR car insurance pays your medical bills and wage loss even if the other driver was completely at fault.  (That’s what MN “No-Fault” means.) You will also have a deductible for that, which you will have to pay or which is deducted from the payments your insurance company makes to you.

If you have questions after an accident about getting repaid for the damage to your car or your insurance deductible, you are welcome to call us and speak with a lawyer for a free consultation. If you have been injured in an auto accident in MN, you should call us as soon as possible so that a lawyer can investigate your case and advise you of your rights. The primary focus of our car accident lawyers it to make sure you receive all of the benefits you are entitled to.